Shimano XT 11 speed drivetrain review
November 11th, 2015
By Andrew Dodd in Reviews
21 weeks on XT, with minimal maintenance
Earlier this year, we headed out to Les Arcs to check out the brand new Shimano XT 11 speed drivetrain – which can be snapped up for under £405, compared to the SRAM GX at a smidge under £450. I took my trusty Mondraker Foxy XR Carbon with me, and got to bolt on the blacked out drive train before hitting the trails.
It’s been 5months of riding since then – some in ultra dry and dusty conditions, and other times in the foul mess we call sometimes call Autumn over here. Read on to see what we think of the Shimano XT 11speed drivetrain with some decent trail time on it…
When we arrived in Les Arcs, I got to work fitting the 11 speed transmission to my long term test bike with the help of Shimano technician Peter Griffiths. The riding around Les Arcs is incredible – and a hell of a test for brakes, but perhaps not so much for a transmission as we spent a lot of time doing uplift style runs.
Nevertheless, it was a good opportunity to see how smooth things operated; how clean shifting was and how well the retaining chain ring worked. Although my bike had an MRP chain guide on that was also being tested, I removed the upper guide to get a feel of how the chain ring worked. The lack of narrow/wide profile teeth definitely raised eye brows, but proved to be reliable. Time would tell if this continued, as often chainrings get worn and lose some of the retention – though the Shimano crew assured us that the chainring would wear in, and not out.
Retention shouldn’t decrease in time.
21 weeks later
Stripping my bike down for routine maintenance, I decided to pull the whole drivetrain off and inspect it to see what sort of state it is in.
Since initial installation I’ve tried to avoid over cleaning, or lubricating and have generally let nature take it’s toll. The transmission has still been running quietly, and I’ve not yet lost the chain. I’ve also noticed that the Shimano chainring runs quieter than other retaining chainrings I’ve used.
It does hold a layer of grime near the chain though, like most other chainrings, bar the Renthal offering with it’s mud extruding channels. I’ve not had the grime build up enough to affect shifting or chain retention though, and it’s not made any difference to riding.
Instead of using a thick thin profiled tooth design, Shimano use a very deep trough that is slightly hooked forwards slightly. This means as the chain and ring wear, the chainring won’t lose effectiveness. Shimano say that they do not guarantee you won’t lose your chain with this system, but ours has been as good as gold to date. Bear in mind that performance on a hardtail, or with certain suspension designs may affect this.
Our rear mech has glanced off several rocks through the summer – some were hits that we half expected to lose the mech completely. As a result, our mech does have a small amount of play, but it shifts just as cleanly . The clutch mechanism has also remained tight, and we’ve not needed to manually adjust tension to date. If we’re being picky, we would say the rear mech is one of the uglier designs out there, but it really does work excellently.
Unlike the SRAM 11 speed cassettes that use a 10-42 spread, Shimano use an 11tooth sprocket in order to continue using the conventional cassette body design. This is great for users on a budget, and in case you wonder the Shimano cassette does work with a SRAM chain, and mech. And vice versa. Shifting has been flawless from the £80 cassette – although as our test bike is also used for commuting we did miss the 10tooth that SRAM offer. If you rarely spin out your biggest gears, you can live without it.
Shimano shifters always have a good feel, although the shifting action can be a little light for some. The 11 speed Xt shifter has a reassuring clunk about it though, and a very smooth action. We love that the down-shift lever allows for double down shifts – though it only does this if pushed with your thumb. Using your index finger will only change a single gear. As big fans of the XTR shifter, we’d rather it could double shift both ways, but it’s still one-up on SRAM’s single click action. The i-Sync II system is great for mounting the lever, though we did have to take a file to the inside edge of the clamp as it was scoring carbon bars.
Even with the press fit BB90, we never suffered from a creaky BB, and our unit is still perfectly smooth. The cranks too are as straight as new, and we’ve not had chainring bolts rattle loose. The finish is starting to dull down a little toward to top of the cranks where certain shoes rub on the cranks – but nowhere near as badly as the XTR cranks. Our cranks are still black, and look good.
As we mentioned, we’ve avoided maintenance as much as possible – only clearing off the worst mud and grime and leaving enough trail scum on there to unveil problems. Nothing to report though – the Shimano XT 11 speed drive train is working a treat.
Alp d’Huez earlier this year was the driest we’ve ever seen. The lower wooded section of the Megavalanche course dried out everything to the point of squeaking, but a little lube and the XT transmission was back to business. Photo | Callum Jelley
Verbier was on the damp side compared to the dusty French trails we’ve ridden this year, but not enough to put a dampener on the XT performance. Only a few rock strikes questioned things – a bent lower jockey cage was bent back by hand, and still works just as it did originally. Photo | Callum Jelley
£402.93 as you see it. Impeccable shifting; near silent running and keeps on churning. We’re now going to fully clean up this drivetrain, and install it on a new test frame. We’ve no doubt it will be fit and forget again.
We say
Shimano has been at the forefront of bike transmissions since mountain biking began, and whilst they’ve made a few odd choices over the years with things like Dual Control, and Rapid Rise – whenever they’ve been a little slower to market, the products have always shone.
We knew XT 11 speed would be good. Sure, it’s not quite as glam as the SRAM equivalent, but Shimano is well known for no-nonsense. The Shimano XT 11 speed drivetrain is great value for money; works incredibly well and offers very good value for money. We can’t recommend it highly enough.
What drive train do you run?
Are you a SRAM man, or a loyal Shimano user?
Let us know in the comments below…
Comments
comments
In Reviews
TAGS